Mary Yoder's Bakery G6D52619.jpg
 
Mary Yoder's Amish Kitchen
 
Books
 
Gifts and Things
 
Jams & Noodles
 
Gift Certificates
 
Homemade and Handmade
While we will do everything possible to assure that your bakery products arrive in excellent condition, we cannot be responsible for the condition upon arrival or damage incurred during shipping, including handling, extreme temperatures, and shipment delays beyond our control. Pies, bread, and cookies must ship priority mail for freshest delivery.
   
peanutbutterspread.jpg Amish Peanut Butter Spread
$4.99
It is traditional in Amish homes to mix peanut butter with maple syrup and other sweeteners to produce this creamy peanut butter spread. The Amish ladies at Mary Yoder's have perfected this recipe, creating a peanut butter lover's delight which is always in high demand at Mary Yoder's.
Quantity

   
applebutter.jpg Mary Yoder's Apple Butter
$4.99
Another Amish tradition happens in the fall when the apples are harvested. Picture a huge kettle hanging over an open fire in the back yard, with someone stirring and adding the right blend of cinnamon and other spices. While we don't do this outside, we do cook our apple butter in a big kettle in our bakery. Often, as it is cooking down, the heady aroma draws our guests to the bakery door to find out just what that tantalizing smell is!
Quantity

   
piepic2 Mary Yoder's Amish Pies
$10.69
The Amish ladies in our bakery make the pie fillings and the crusts, using the recipes that have been favorites for years. Many people come to Mary Yoder's just to sample our delicious pies. Choose your favorites at check out and we will ship them fresh. Sorry, we cannot ship cream pies or crumb topping pies. Kinds available include apple, cherry, rhubarb and strawberry rhubarb.
Choose the number of pies you would like, and list the kinds. Priority shipping only.

Quantity

   
piepic2 Mary Yoder's Sugar Free Pies
$11.29
Those who watch their sugar intake can still enjoy an Amish made pie from Mary Yoder's. The Amish ladies in our bakery use Splenda to sweeten many of our most requested pies. Choose from apple, blueberry, blackberry, cherry, elderberry, red raspberry and rhubarb.
Choose the number of pies and the kinds to be shipped. Priority shipping only.

Quantity

   
piepic2 Mary Yoder's Specialty Pies
$11.29
The Amish ladies in our bakery make the pie fillings and the crusts, using the recipes that have been favorites for years. Many people come to Mary Yoder's just to sample our delicious pies. Choose your favorites at check out and we will ship them fresh. Sorry, we cannot ship cream pies or crumb topping pies. Kinds available include blackberry, blueberry, bumbleberry, elderberry, german chocolate, and peach.
Choose from the following pies:

Quantity

   
cookie-selection Mary Yoder's Specialty Cookies
$0.79
The Amish ladies in our bakery make so many mouth-watering cookies, and often they are sold out before the day is through. You won't be disappointed, however, because you can place your order here, and be sure to get the cookies you want.
Choose from the following cookies:

Quantity

   
cookie-selection Mary Yoder's Cookies
$0.69
The Amish ladies in our bakery make so many mouth-watering cookies, and often they are sold out before the day is through. You won't be disappointed, however, because you can place your order here, and be sure to get the cookies you want.
Choose the kind of cookies and the quantity.

Quantity

   
bread-white.jpg White Bread
$2.99
One of the benefits of being at Mary Yoder's early in the morning is the tantalizing aroma of fresh bread, just out of the oven. Our Amish bakers arrive in the wee hours of the morning to start the bread that is served in our dining room and offered for sale on the bakery counter. Your order will be baked and shipped the same day. For optimum freshness, choose priority shipping. Ingredients include wheat flour, malted barley flour, soybean oil, polyglycerides, sugar, salt, vinegar, yeast, water, and citric acid. 20 ounce loaf.
Choose slicing options.

Quantity

   
bread-rye-web.jpg Rye Bread
$2.99
If you enjoy rye bread, you will love this Amish-made rye. Ingredients include wheat and barley bread flour, water, rye flour, soybean oil, yeast, brown sugar, salt, caraway seed, vinegar, and citric acid. 20 ounce loaf.
Choose slicing options.

Quantity

   
bread-honey-wheat-web.jpg Honey Wheat Bread
$2.99
A tasty wheat bread, this is the bread for those who like whole wheat. Ingredients include wheat and barley bread flour, water, whole wheat flour, soybean oil, honey, yeast, salt, vinegar, and citric acid. 20 ounce loaf.
Choose slicing options.

Quantity

   
bread-cinnamon-raisin.jpg Raisin Cinnamon Bread
$2.99
Our raisin cinnamon bread makes excellent toast, and is perfect for making French toast. Ingredients include wheat and barley bread flour, water, raisins, soybean oil, yeast, sugar, cinnamon, vinegar, and citric acid. 20 ounce oaf.
Choose slicing options.

Quantity

   
bread-sour-dough.jpg Sourdough Bread
$3.39
This old-fashioned bread begins with a yeast starter, and is a delicous, healthy white bread. Ingredients include wheat and barley bread flour, water, instant potato flakes, sugar, soybean oil, yeast, salt, and citric acid. 20 ounce loaf.
Choose slicing options.

Quantity

   
Multi grain bread
$3.99
This is a soft, flavorful grain bread made from wheat, rye, barley, oats, and topped with sesame seeds. The loaves weigh 1 1/2 pounds. Ingredients include: enriched wheat flour (niacin,reduced iron, riboflavin), cracked rye, barley flakes, wheat bran, rolled oats, sesame seeds, yeast, corn syrup, vegetable oil, wheat gluten, salt, mono & diglycerides, enzymes, and ascorbic acid.
Choose slicing options.

Quantity

   
bread-French-web.jpg French Bread
$2.99
Amish made French bread! Ingredients include wheat flour, malted barley flour, soybean oil, polyglycerides, sugar, salt, vinegar, yeast, water, milk, egg, cornmeal, and citric acid. 20 ounce loaf.
Choose slicing options.

Quantity

   
Whoopie pie
$1.99
Treat yourself to one of our favorites! Two large, soft, chocolate cookies filled with vanilla icing make this a special delight. Whoopie pies are about 5 inches in diameter and 1 1/2 inches thick, and weigh between 7 and 8 ounces each.
Quantity

   
Oatmeal pie
$1.99
For oatmeal cookie lovers, this is the best! Creamy vanilla icing is generously sandwiched between two large, soft oatmeal cookies. The oatmeal pie is about 5 inches in diameter, and about 1 1/4 inches thick, and weighs between 7 and 8 ounces.
Quantity